Knowing neo-Grec (part 1)

Neo-Grec brownstone row house facade with incised geometric lintels in the Brooklyn Heights Historic District
Neo-Grec row house in the Brooklyn Heights Historic District.

The neo-Grec is one of those styles that seems skipped over; you hear a few key phrases like flattened facades, incised details, neo-Grec fluting, or “Eastlake designs,” and then you move on to the next style. But when you start to think about what determines “flatness” on the facades of New York City row houses, it starts to create confusion. For me, confusion quickly turned to doubt. I started to wonder where that line was drawn, when was a facade flat enough to have a molded lintel and still be considered neo-Grec and not Italianate? When was there enough incising to make a building neo-Grec? How much fluting was needed to counter a three-dimensional foliate door hood? The voices of co-workers and mentors telling me “you know it when you see it” only made me question how we could so widely use a style determination that seemed largely missing in academic literature.

Neo-Grec row house facade detail in East Harlem with shallow projecting lintels and incised ornament
A neo-Grec favorite in East Harlem.

As I started the deep-dive into the neo-Grec, I found that over forty years ago this same debate moved through my office, and while it was settled on behalf of the neo-Grec as an architectural style, there was little written or recorded to memorialize that argument or understand the resolution. I began hunting for neo-Grec in situ, and I began to see it everywhere. Incised details on a transitional Italianate row house; neo-Grec patterns all over cast-iron facades in SoHo, again in Ladies Mile; flattened window enframements on a circa-1880 row house in Brooklyn, again — same enframements — in Harlem.

Now I’ve developed a relationship with neo-Grec. While living in New York I saw it everywhere; I spotted its elements and characteristics in the crowded streetscapes of Manhattan and Brooklyn. My preservation friends have started to send me photos from other cities and other countries, and those closest to me think that New York City’s row houses must have been built by an army of speculative builders with a vast collection of neo-Grec building elements for how often I talk about it. Now that I live in California, I am trying to understand its absence, or whether it is in fact here but hidden in misidentified trends and characteristics attributed to other styles.

Beginning to record this dialogue and nerdy architectural journey through Knowing neo-Grec is a way for me to assemble the information I find and the visuals I continue to assemble, and allows me to create a place to record the ways that others view this strangely controversial style, but maybe most importantly, it is a way to satiate my curiosity. I hope that others who are curious about the neo-Grec, or have always liked the decorative quality of the style, are willing to share their knowledge and maybe even share the neo-Grec buildings that they stumble across.

Please peruse my growing collection of neo-Grec building details on Instagram (@knowing_neogrec) or on my personal website. You can find part 2 of this series here, as well as parts three, four, and five. If you would like to connect professionally, please visit Reiter Preservation Consulting.

Commercial cast-iron facade in Tribeca displaying neo-Grec incised pilasters and geometric brackets
Commercial cast-iron building with neo-Grec design in Tribeca, New York City.